Background

This ruling forms part of a wider piece of work looking at paid-for ads for shared ownership properties, identified for investigation following intelligence gathered by the ASA. See also related rulings published on 18 November 2026. 

Ad description

A paid-for website display ad and a property listing on the OnTheMarket website, seen on 8 April 2026: 
 
a. The display ad stated “2 bedroom semi-detached bungalow for sale. From £107,500” beneath an image of the property. A clickable button labelled “Find out more”, which led to ad (b), was included at the bottom of the ad. 
 
b. The property listing stated “Shared ownership” in small grey text above the “£107,500” price of the property. Text beneath the “Key information” section stated “Tenure: Leasehold 50% share rental £325pcm 72yrs left.” Further text, located under the “Features and description” sub-heading stated “To be sold on 50% shared ownership”. 
 
When the “Features and description” section was expanded, text stated “TENURE: The house is Leasehold over 99 years from August 1st 1998 with 72 years remaining. RENT. Rent payable is £325 per month.”

Issue

The ASA challenged whether the ads misleadingly omitted material information.

Response

OnTheMarket Ltd said they had prepared the paid-for display ad, but the property listing had been supplied by Edward Mellor Ltd, who were responsible for its content. They said that information in the listing was input by the estate agent, and OnTheMarket had no means of independently verifying the underlying property information. They stated that because of the volume of listings OnTheMarket hosted, there were practical and technical limits on checking all listing information for accuracy and completeness. However, if they became aware of an issue, they would remove a listing where necessary. 
 
They said the listing page made clear that the property was offered on a shared ownership basis. It stated “Shared ownership” above the price and, under “Key information”, included the text “Leasehold”, “50% share”, “rent of £325 per month” and “72 years remaining”. The shared ownership arrangement was also repeated in the property description. They said that service charges would only appear where supplied by the agent. They added that property transactions commonly involved further information being provided offline, and that a listing could not include every detail that might be relevant to an individual purchaser. Regarding shared ownership eligibility requirements, they said those requirements could be complex and change over time. They also questioned whether including minimum and maximum salary requirements could raise concerns about profiling or discrimination. 
 
They said the display ad acted as a signpost to the full listing and was subject to space restrictions. They believed consumers would not rely on the display ad alone when making an important decision about a property, and said the linked listing provided the necessary information about the shared ownership arrangement, and therefore they did not accept that either the display ad or listing had been materially misleading. 
 
The display ad was no longer active and the listing had been removed after receipt of the complaint. Without accepting fault, they said they would seek to include “shared ownership” in current and future display ads, and they would work with the ASA on future guidance for advertising shared ownership properties. 
 
Edward Mellor Ltd said they had used information supplied by the seller and housing association in the listing. 
 
They said that the listing itself disclosed the £325 monthly rent. They said that at the time the property was originally marketed, the information provided to them stated that the monthly rent was £325. They subsequently received more detailed information from the housing association which stated that the total monthly payment was in fact £375.30, comprising rent of £249.09, a £112.52 service charge and £13.70 of insurance, at which point they updated their marketing communications to reflect that change. 
 
Edward Mellor said that neither the seller, nor the housing association had supplied any eligibility wording or qualifying criteria for shared ownership, and as such, it was not included in the ad, as was their normal practice to do. They also confirmed that the property appeared to be subject to a further eligibility restriction requiring residents to be aged 55 or over. They said that neither the seller’s representative nor the housing association provided them with details of an over-55 occupation restriction. They recognised that both eligibility for shared ownership and the over-55 occupation restriction were material information for consumers. 
 
They were also unable to confirm whether the property was formally classified as part of the Older Persons Shared Ownership (OPSO) scheme. 
 
They stated that it was not their normal practice as estate agents to obtain and undertake a legal examination of the full lease before commencing marketing. They therefore relied upon information obtained through the seller and other relevant parties, including housing associations where applicable. They said that had they been made aware of these restrictions, they would have included them within their marketing particulars because there would be no commercial benefit to them in attracting enquiries from prospective purchasers who would not qualify to purchase the property. 
 
They said they had reviewed their procedures and, in future, would seek to ensure that shared ownership listings stated the full details of the arrangement.

Assessment

Upheld

The CAP Code stated that marketing communications must not mislead consumers by omitting material information, including providing such information in a way that was unclear or untimely. Material information was information that consumers needed to make an informed transactional decision. 
 
The ASA understood that shared ownership was a form of home ownership in which consumers bought a share of a property and paid rent on the remaining share, which was usually owned by a housing association or other provider. The total cost of shared ownership could include mortgage payments on the share purchased, rent on the remaining share and other charges associated with the property, such as monthly service charges or ground rent. The scheme was intended to make home ownership more accessible to those who might not otherwise have been able to afford to buy a property. We considered that those entering shared ownership agreements were likely to be first-time buyers in many cases, although we acknowledged that some schemes were aimed at specific groups of consumers and had additional eligibility criteria, such as age restrictions. 
 
We understood that consumers would first see the paid-for display ad (ad (a)), which linked through to the property listing on OnTheMarket's website (ad (b)). We acknowledged that Edward Mellor had provided OnTheMarket with the property information shown in ad (b) and was responsible for its content. However, we considered that both Edward Mellor Ltd and OnTheMarket Ltd were responsible for the paid-for display ad (ad (a)). 
 
We considered that consumers would understand from the display ad (ad (a)) that the two-bedroom semi-detached bungalow was available to buy, and that £107,500 was the price of the property. However, we understood that the property was available on a shared ownership basis, and that the advertised price of £107,500 related to only a 50% share of the property. Consumers would therefore be required to pay rent on the remaining share, in addition to other applicable costs. We considered that the shared ownership arrangement was material information because it significantly affected the nature of the property being offered, and the basis on which consumers would understand the advertised price. Although we acknowledged that display ads could be subject to some space constraints, we considered that the ad was not sufficiently limited by time or space to justify the omission of that information. Because ad (a) did not make clear that the price referred to a 50% share of a property offered under a shared ownership scheme, we concluded that it omitted material information. 
 
Clicking on “Find out more” took consumers to the OnTheMarket property listing (ad (b)). It included the text “Shared ownership” above the price, “50% share” under “Key information” and “To be sold on 50% shared ownership” further down the page. We considered that consumers would understand from ad (b) that the property was available on a shared ownership basis, and that the price related to a 50% share.  However, while ad (b) made that clear, we considered that was insufficient because the information had not been included in the initial display ad (ad (a)). 
 
We considered consumers would understand from the claim “Tenure: Leasehold 50% share rental £325pcm 72yrs left” that the property was available on a leasehold basis, and that a monthly rent of £325 applied to the property. However, we understood that the total monthly charge including the service charge and insurance was £375.30 and that the figure of £325 had been stated in error. Notwithstanding that error, we considered that the ad should have made clear that a service charge applied and how much it was, because this was an additional cost and could change over time, which could affect the property’s monthly affordability for consumers. 
 
We also understood that eligibility criteria, such as a maximum salary, applied for shared ownership properties, and that many consumers would not meet the criteria for buying the advertised property. We further understood that this specific property was subject to an occupation restriction, which required residents to be retired from full-time employment, and aged 55 or over. We considered that restriction was material information because it significantly limited who could live in the property. 
 
Because ad (b) did not state that a service charge applied or specify its amount; make clear that eligibility criteria applied for the shared ownership scheme or provide a link to those criteria and nor did it state that residents of the property were required to be retired from full-time employment and aged 55 or over, we concluded that the ad omitted material information. 
 
We acknowledged OnTheMarket Ltd’s view that further information would commonly be provided offline to a potential buyer during a property transaction. However, we considered that the key terms of the shared ownership arrangement and restrictions on the property should have been made clear in the ads, and that the ads were not sufficiently limited by time or space for this information not to have been included. 
 
We concluded that the ads omitted material information that consumers required in order to make an informed transactional decision, and were therefore misleading. 
 
The ads breached CAP Code (Edition 12) rules 3.1, 3.3, 3.4 and 3.4.1 (Misleading Advertising).

Action

The ads must not appear again in the form complained of. We told OnTheMarket Ltd and Edward Mellor Ltd to ensure that future ads for shared ownership properties did not misleadingly omit material information. We told them to ensure that paid-for display ads did not misleadingly omit that the property was offered on a shared ownership basis and the percentage share represented by the advertised price. We told Edward Mellor Ltd to ensure that listing ads did not misleadingly omit the fact that a service charge applied and the amount, and that eligibility criteria for the shared ownership scheme applied and a link to those criteria. We told Edward Mellor Ltd not to misleadingly omit material information that a property was subject to an occupation restriction. 

CAP Code (Edition 12)

3.1     3.3     3.4     3.4.1    


More on